About Eric Fontana

Restaurant Gems of Pittsburgh Restaurant Reviews

Image

About Eric Fontana

Restaurant Gems OF PITTSBURGH Restaurant Reviews

It's a pretty familiar thought..."Where should we go out tonight?"

"I know what I don't want!" someone chimes in.

"I don't care where we go as long as I don't have to go through the Squirrel Hill tunnel!" another says, not kidding.

"I only have $10..."

Perhaps you've been here before.

There are so many great bars and restaurants in the Pittsburgh area...

...but finding reliable information on the internet can feel like an exercise in futility.

How many fake-sounding Yelp reviews can you read before you throw in the towel and hit up the Olive Garden?

I'm here to tell you that you do not need to settle for the "same old" with so much to experience in Pittsburgh, and you do not need to spend a fortune to have an amazing time.

There is another way! But first, a little background...

At Penn State, I discovered a site called the State College Bar Tour.

It had all the drink specials at every bar, every day of the week. It was updated weekly.

As most of you know, when you are in college, funds are limited, having access to see where you can drink cheap in college is a huge asset. This was the first time I was like, "wow, how useful to have this information available any time, right at your fingertips - tailored to my location and written by people I trust!"

As I moved on from my college years, I noticed a lack of the same tools for the general public.

Sure, I could sift through reviews of bars and restaurants in Pittsburgh on Google or Yelp until the cows came home...but I never felt like I could really trust what I was reading.

Additionally, there wasn't a single place I could go to see all of the best specials of the week to decide where to spend my cash.

Thus, Restaurant Gems Restaurant Reviews of Pittsburgh began!

I started small, posting reviews on Facebook for fun. It grew from there as people found my reviews helpful, thorough, and sometimes even comical.

My ultimate goal is to help everyday Pittsburghers find hidden restaurant gems that won’t break the bank.

Think of me as your good friend who has tried the best restaurants in and around the city, giving you reviews you know you can trust. That's what this website is all about.

I have written restaurant articles for applications and newspapers, appeared on the radio, am working on my second Pittsburgh restaurant book, and am starting to become well known in the Pittsburgh area as I visit all different types of restaurants from all over the area.

You can get started by reading some of my reviews below!


Are You Here For...

Restaurants

Find Restaurants

Breweries

Find Breweries


On Facebook:

🍁🍁🍁 Zelienople Fall Festival, America’s Small Town. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook

16 hours ago

Restaurant Gems of Pittsburgh and Ohio Valley and More
🥯 BUTLER COUNTY, are you in the mood for Sourdough Bakery products? Check out this family run bakery! FARMHOUSE FANCIES!🍞 Handcrafted Sourdough in Butler County, PANaturally leavened breads, scones, cookies & seasonal bakes made with organic flour + clean ingredients — baked fresh in cast iron for real flavor.🧀 Charcuterie boards & sourdough assortments available for events, weddings & gatherings.🏪 Wholesale inquiries: Call Shaun → 724-900-3229❤️ Family-owned. Made by hand, with purpose.📦 Order by Sat @ 12PM → Pickup Wed after 11AM📍 104 Serene Lane, Butler, PAWebsite - bakesy.shop/b/farmhouse-fancies ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
🙏 A special thanks to Ya Jagoff! for having me on as one of their guest! The episode will be airing soon! What a great experience and great bunch of people! ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook

3 days ago

Restaurant Gems of Pittsburgh and Ohio Valley and More
🥓 Bringing Cranberry Township Together: The Hometown Diner Pittsburgh’s Fastest-Growing Suburb Needed!1185 Freedom RoadCranberry Township, PA 16066 🤔 As major construction to widen Freedom Road for the influx of businesses and residential development is upon us, Cranberry Township has been thirsting for a diner that creates a place where great food, warm hospitality, and friendly environment that makes everyone feel like family. Bennie’s Diner has answered the call and is already a huge hit! Let’s dig into why this spot should be your go-to destination for unbeatable Breakfast and Lunch! 🌶️ At Bennie’s Diner, quality is never compromised—especially when it comes to ingredients. Benny’s uses fresh ingredients and everything is crafted with care and intention. It’s this commitment to freshness that sets them apart and brings real flavor to every bite!🍤 The dish everyone is raving about = Shrimp and Grits-This dish features creamy, cheesy grits blended with sautéed peppers and onions, crowned with juicy, perfectly seared shrimp and crispy bacon crumbles. A drizzle of Benny’s signature hot honey glaze brings a bold balance of sweet and heat, while house-pickled jalapeños add a zesty kick. A crave-worthy combo of savory and sweet, this dish hits the spot any time of day—perfect for breakfast or lunch.🥓 Breakfast items - If you’re looking for other items to indulge in, you can go with Chicken and Waffles or Bennie’s Hash which is made from scratch! It features your choice of Corned Beef or Chorizo Hash topped with two poached eggs and comes with sliced toast. Bennie’s also has delectable Omelets, Breakfast Classics, French Toast, Pancakes, Eggs Benedict’s, and more!🥪 Lunch - If you’re looking to grab Lunch you can go with one of their handhelds which includes a Chicken Sandwich, BLT, Salmon BLT, Fish Sandwich, Club Sandwich, Rueben, or Philly Cheesesteak. Try a Pittsburgh Style salad with their housemade ranch. Build your own burger, savor one of their hearty soups, or try an open face sandwich.💡 Tip - A quick tip, this place gets very busy at peak Breakfast hours. They are open from 7am to 2pm. Consider using that whole window and grabbing Lunch or a late Breakfast if need be!🧐 My final take - I’ve been to countless restaurants over the past decade, and I can always tell when an owner pours real heart into their establishment. Bennie’s embodies that passion. Their mission—centered on family, quality, hospitality, passion, pride, generosity, fun, teamwork, and integrity—isn’t just words on a wall. They live it. And it shows. The momentum is already building, and I have no doubt: Bennie’s is on track to become a breakout favorite in the Butler and Beaver County area. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook

4 days ago

Restaurant Gems of Pittsburgh and Ohio Valley and More
🎉 A TRUE OHIO VALLEY LEGEND — DiCarlo’s Pizza 🍕📍 Whether you’re cruising west to Wheeling or Columbus, heading south to Morgantown, or venturing east toward Washington D.C., chances are you’ve passed through the heart of Washington County — a place where West Virginia and Ohio meet, taxes are low, and the attractions are big. From The Meadows Racetrack & Casino to Tanger Outlets, Southpointe Golf Club, and Cabela’s, it’s a hidden gem with real flavor… literally.🧀 Now, I’ll admit it — I’m picky when it comes to food (just ask my fiancé 😅). But one dish I’ll never get tired of? Pizza. It’s affordable, versatile, and hits every time. Fun fact: Pizza didn’t really take off in the U.S. until after World War II. Fast forward to now — we’re devouring 3 BILLION pizzas a year in this country. And honestly? A good chunk of that should be DiCarlo’s.🔥 For over 75 years, DiCarlo’s Pizza has been serving up their signature style: a crispy homemade crust, simple yet bold tomato sauce, and a finishing touch of freshly grated provolone (yep — not mozzarella). The result? A slice that’s crunchy, cheesy, and unforgettable.👀 It may look like thin New York-style at first glance, but don’t be fooled — the crust’s got just the right heft to satisfy without overpowering. The provolone gives it that extra kick — sharp, rich, and packed with flavor.✅ FINAL TAKE: DiCarlo’s doesn’t just make pizza — they craft it. With fresh ingredients, old-school values, and a no-frills, high-flavor menu, every bite screams solid. Around here, we say:“You plant corn, you get corn.”Well, DiCarlo’s planted passion — and what they got? Legendary pizza.👇 If you’ve had DiCarlo’s, drop your favorite location or memory below!💬 Never tried it? Tag someone who needs to go. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook